There are two ways to give your talent a tally light: buy dedicated hardware, or use a browser-based software solution. Both work. They serve different production contexts. This guide breaks down the real differences so you can choose the right one for your setup.
The Core Difference
Hardware tally lights receive a signal from your video switcher over a local network. Browser tally lights receive a signal from a cloud server over the internet. That one difference — local vs cloud — cascades into everything else.
| Factor | Hardware Tally | Browser Tally (Cue Light) |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | $200–$600 per unit | Free |
| Network | Local WiFi / wired only | Works over internet |
| Setup time | Minutes to hours | 30 seconds |
| Device needed | Dedicated tally unit | Any phone or tablet |
| Remote guests | ✗ Not supported | ✓ Share a link |
| Switcher integration | ✓ Automatic from switcher | Manual (director taps) |
| Reliability | Very high (dedicated hardware) | High (cloud infrastructure) |
| Venue dependency | Requires stable local network | Works on cellular |
When Hardware Tally Wins
Hardware tally lights are the right choice when:
- You have a permanent, wired studio. Broadcast studios with dedicated infrastructure benefit from automatic switcher integration — when Camera 1 goes live, its tally light turns red automatically without anyone tapping a button.
- You run high-stakes multi-camera production where you can't afford any manual coordination overhead.
- Your budget allows it and you want maximum reliability with zero human error in the tally signal.
Bottom line on hardware: If you're a broadcast network or a permanent production facility, dedicated hardware is worth the investment. For everyone else, the cost-to-benefit ratio doesn't hold up.
When Browser Tally Wins
Browser-based tally is the right choice for the vast majority of modern video production:
- You shoot in different locations. Weddings, events, corporate shoots — you can't pre-rig hardware tally at every venue.
- You have remote guests. Hardware tally physically cannot signal someone on Zoom. Browser tally can.
- You work with volunteers or rotating crew. A church with a new camera operator every Sunday doesn't want to teach hardware configuration. Scan a QR code — done.
- Your budget is limited. Free vs $400+ per unit is a real consideration for independent creators and small productions.
- Your venue WiFi is unreliable. Browser tally runs over cellular — venue network is irrelevant.
The Manual vs Automatic Trade-Off
The main limitation of browser-based tally is that someone has to tap the button. With hardware tally integrated to your switcher, the signal is automatic — cut to Camera 2, Camera 2's light turns red instantly without human input.
In practice, this matters less than it sounds. Most productions already have a director or TD who is actively switching. Adding a tap to Cue Light alongside a switcher cut takes under a second. Keyboard shortcuts (1 = Live, 2 = Preview, 3 = Standby) make it even faster. For the cost and flexibility benefit, most productions find the trade-off completely acceptable.
Can You Use Both?
Yes — and many productions do. A church might use ATEM's built-in tally for on-camera operators who are hardwired on the local network, while using Cue Light to signal the speaker on stage (who's on cellular) and a remote campus in a different city. The two systems complement each other.
Try browser tally for free
No hardware to buy. Open Cue Light on your phone and you have a working tally light in 30 seconds.
Start free — no signup